What Kind of Blog Comments Should be Approved?

Last Updated on

Spam comments – this is something that WE (blog owners), have to deal with… At first – when you're just starting out you don't see that as a problem, but as soon as your blog grows – you'll start to receive comments left by bots and automated software.

StartBloggingOnline.com gets approximately 100 new comments per month, unfortunately 75% of them are spam comments.

Here is an example of comments that are so-called “spam”:
Spam comments left by bots
  • Save

The sample above is obvious for both of us. But some spam comments often look like they are left by real humans:

Hey, I came across your blog and I found it very useful. However, what you think about my site here: hxxp://spam-site.com

or this:

Want to start your own site? Check out my step-by-step tutorial on how to start a blog.

Do you want to get better rankings on Google? Check my SEO services here: hxxp://seoservicesblabla.com

Those people are only commenting your blog because they want to place their website links on your blog or get some sort of benefit from you.

It's wise to mark them as spam as soon as you see them. However, it's important that you still check all the comments manually because there may still be real comments that can be very valuable to you and your readers. Comments help to start great discussions and conversations, so this is the reason why you should check them through and always answer to your readers.

Comments made by real people are often expressing their opinion and views on the discussed post or topic. They can also be formed as questions. For example:

Hey Mike, I read your post about blog comments and I was wondering maybe you can suggest me some plugins that automatically block spam on my site. Thanks.

How to block “spam comments”?

Unless you receive over 20 blog comments per day, there is no need to use any special plugins. If you feel that you are tired of deleting those ugly-looking comments every other day then download the akismet plugin. There are also other options like deleting the “Website field” from the WordPress comment section, but that requires some basic WordPress coding knowledge.

 

Akismet plugin

Actually, if you are using WordPress, it's already pre-installed to your plugins section. You just need to activate it, but you also need to know that it will cost $5/month per one site.

If you have several different blogs, it will cost you $50 per month. So it's totally up to you whether you want to delete those spam comments manually or get them blocked by Akismet plugin. Always keep in mind that Akismet will not block all the spammy comments. The success rate is about 90%, which means it will delete 900 spam comments out of every 1000 spam comments that are posted.

In short, Akismet is a hosted web service that automatically detects comments and trackback spam. It will block most of the spam comments automatically, and if needed, it will also ask for a captcha code.

sample of akismet
  • Save

 

Disabling or limiting blog comments

Another option is to turn comments entirely off. If you have a business site built on WordPress without a “blog” section, then contact form is more than enough to get information and questions from customers and visitors who are interested in your company. It does have one negative aspect which is no conversation and engaging with your audience, but for a professional company site, they are not necessarily needed.

I've been trying different methods and in my opinion, deleting the “Website” field from WordPress comments works best. If there is no link option in the comments section, a lot of spammers won't post anything at all.

Here is the trick how to remove the field: Add the code below in your Functions.php file and you're done.

add_filter(‘comment_form_default_fields', ‘url_filtered');
function url_filtered($fields)
{
if(isset($fields[‘url']))
unset($fields[‘url']);
return $fields;
}
 
 

Conclusion

The bigger your audience and traffic grows, the more you're going to get spammy comments and at one point your quality comments get lost between them. So, there are some things you could do to prevent that. First, install the necessary plugins. Secondly, remove the “Website” field from the comments section and a lot of spammers won't bother you anymore. This is how I've survived and managed to handle the spam stream.

I've done quite a lot of research on that topic and Disqus seems to be another good commenting platform for blogs and websites. Some old school guys only optimize WordPress settings and they say they have managed to keep their blogs free of spam comments. I'm probably going to write a post about that in the near future.

Update June 2019: I'm now using the WordPress plugin named Anti-spam cleantalk. I have to say that I'm pretty much blown away by this. It works brilliantly and 98% of the spam comments get automatically blocked. It costs $8 per year, but you don't need to spend hours to moderate spam comments out of real comments. They also run a free trial of 14 days so I highly suggest you to give it a try.

Let me know which tactics you use and what are the best anti-spam strategies for you and your blog.

  • Save

5 thoughts on “What Kind of Blog Comments Should be Approved?”

  1. Hi Karen,

    1. About Akismet.
    I have read a lot of articles about Akismet and comments. They all say Akismet works very, very bad with comments.

    2. I don’t understand what “Website field” you are talking about. For example, here you offer a field called Website. It is obvious you are not referring to this.

    Where is that field that must be deleted?

    1. Hey Silviu,
      Thanks for stopping by. About your questions…

      1) I’m using akismet right now for another blog and it works quite well in my opinion. $5p/m month is a good investment for that.

      2) The website field is the place where you put the URL. In this case it’s your website (netmarket…). I’m actually referring to this 🙂 I removed it few months ago and put it back again. It worked quite well, I received a lot less “spam” comments.However, the downside of this was that I also got less “real” comments. Some people don’t want to participate in discussions if they can’t reveal their website.

      Hope that helps.

  2. Hi Karen.

    I can see that ‘deleting the website field’ would definitely cur down the spam by 90-95% without a doubt. However, I like the URL option too much and wouldn’t want to take it off my site. I locate too many good webmasters through those links.

    Thanks.

  3. Hy Karen…

    It’s a really nice info for beginners, Since last few days, spam comments have also increased in my website too & it’s a big problem…

    -shubham.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.